Also, you are only at a disadvantage when it comes to sleep. When it comes to behavior and helping, you are at a great advantage. The nursery workers love Brayden. They are constantly aghast at his level of knowledge in various subjects. He sits well and has great focusing skills. He pays attention to the lessons. He is the only child in the nursery who helps clean up the toys. He has no problems being left in the nursery without mom and dad.
This nap disadvantage only lasts really a short period. Most younger babies will sleep in moms arms or the car seat. Older babies are more flexible and able to miss a nap more easily. Also, the nap difficulty hits most toddlers if church falls during a toddler nap. Most toddlers won't sleep in mom's arms anymore. Those moms are left with very cranky children if the child isn't coming into the church already being well-rested in general. A Babywise child knows how to soothe himself and how to work through difficult situations.
As Babywise moms, we are used to very content and happy babies. Kaitlyn gets fussy for her at church most days, but everyone at church is constantly commenting on how happy she is and what a good baby she is. And they are right; she is much easier to handle at church than other children around her age.
Okay, so on to the tips. Whatever your method, remember to always evaluate it and be sure what you are doing is best for your baby's current situation. Your church strategy will need to change often over time.
Naptime is the biggest difficulty for most parents at church.
- If church starts during a nap, there are a couple of options. When Kaitlyn was a young baby, I could put her down, then transfer her to the car seat and she would stay asleep. That was relatively short-lived though. You can also get your child up early on Sunday in order to get a full or at least longer nap in before church.
- If normal naptime starts during church, you also have a couple of options. One is to try to put the child to sleep either in the car seat or your arms. This worked for Kaitlyn for a short period (maybe a month). This worked for Brayden right up until he was a year old. It was a struggle though. We would bounce him in the car seat for 20 minutes, then he would sleep 20-30 minutes. It was just enough to get him through church.
- Another option for naptime that starts during church is to skip it and make up for it later in the day. This is our method with Kaitlyn and was our method with Brayden after he turned a year old. But we didn't lose the nap all together. Once Kaitlyn was at an age where a nap was dropped, I would just give her an extra nap. So she would have an evening nap when she usually didn't. This is a good method when your child still needs to eat every three hours or so.
- You can also extend a nap after church. So you put your child down for the nap early and let her sleep longer. I also often need to put Kaitlyn down early for bed.
- Keep over tiredness in mind. For a long time, I put Kaitlyn down for a nap after church in her swing since I knew she was overtired. I didn't want to expect her to go to sleep on her own when she was so tired. As she got older, it was wasn't a problem.
- Feed early if needed. I have found Kaitlyn will handle missing the nap much easier if she is full. So she drinks her lunch milk 30 minutes early. It really makes a huge difference.
- Snacks. We also bring a lot of snacks for Kaitlyn. This helps keep her happy and preoccupied.
- I didn't bring baby food for either child if church was over a mealtime. I just brought finger foods and fed lunch as soon as we got home.
- We don't let our kids run around and play at church (unless it is in the nursery). They can either sit quietly and play/color/etc. or they can sit still on Daddy's lap out in the hall. There is no playing if we go out in the hall. No walking, no treats, not toys...nothing but sitting still on Daddy's lap. We have never had a problem with behavior at church. This is a policy we put in place before we ever were pregnant with Brayden simply because we observed the results of that vs. playing in the hall with the behavior of children. We have never had to do anything beyond that.
- It is helpful to have toys that only come out at church. We have a church bag packed with toys and books in it that are only available at church each week. This way they stay fresh and interesting for Sunday.
- You have to find the right balance between high enough expectations and not too high of expectations. Find the right balance for your children.
- Church was from 1-4 PM. Kaitlyn spent months 0-8.5 on that schedule. We had a lot of different Sunday schedules and employed all of the ideas listed above. For a while I got her to sleep in my arms. After that, she took a "4th" nap on Sundays but no other day (it was at the 4th nap time, but not an actual 4th nap since she missed one at church). At the end of the year, she came home from church and went straight down for a nap. She then ate a little later for the next feeding.
- Church was from 1-4. This was our schedule from 19 months to 2.5. Brayden took only one nap a day, from 1-4:30. He went to bed an hour early each Sunday night. When he was at the younger end, he would take a short nap before church.
- Church was from 11-2. This was our schedule with Brayden while he was 13-19 months old. This was my favorite schedule. We had to get him up early from a nap and he went down a little late for a nap, but he stayed the happiest because he had shorter naps rather than no naps. He would also go down for the night early if needed.
- Church is now from 9-12. No problem for Brayden (almost 3 years old). Kaitlyn (12 months) misses her morning nap (9:30-11:30). When we get home from church, she eats lunch then goes straight down, which is usually somewhere around 12:45. Her afternoon nap usually starts around 1:45 these days. She then naps until her normal wake up time (3:45-4:00). We also put her down a little early for bed, perhaps 30 minutes.
- [Added February 2009] Church is once again from 11-2. This schedule is absolutely no problem for 3.5 year old Brayden. We get home, he eats lunch, and he takes a short rest period. He rarely falls asleep on Sunday. He doesn't need a nap every day of the week anymore, so we have no problem. For 1.5 year old Kaitlyn, it really isn't a problem either. She is really well behaved at church. Monday, she is tired. She has a shorter nap on Sunday and the time of the nap is very different (tending to start at 2:45ish rather than 1:00). So Monday there is fatigue, but she bounces back.
[Added January 2010]: With church from 11-2, it started off well for McKenna. But by the end of 2009, it was a challenge. She was going down for a nap at 10, but then we had to wake her by 10:45. Then we had to feed her lunch during church. She wasn't quite old enough to just eat finger foods for lunch.
- [Added January 2010]: We now have church from 1-4. This is totally fine for Brayden at 4.5 years old. Any time would be fine for him. It is rough for 2.5 year old Kaitlyn. She typically naps from 1-4:30. The first two week, she was very tired by the end and was on the floor in the nursery saying, "I want to sleep!" By week three, she had adjusted much better, but we will see what the future holds. I think she will get more flexible as time goes on and she gets older. It is a much better time for McKenna than 11 was. She gets to take a full morning nap. She also gets to eat lunch at home. I don't have to feed her at church at all. She typically naps from 2/2:20ish to 4:30ish, so it does take up her second nap. She doesn't sleep at church. What we do is get home, feed her dinner, then put her down for a nap. She sleeps until about 7:30, then I get her up, feed her, do pjs, story, etc. and put her back to bed. It works really well. She does have a bit shorter than normal waketimes on Monday, but not too bad.
- Nicole Viola said...
Hi! Our church service is from 9~11ish, which of course, is smack dab during naptime for our 12-mo. old, Gigi. Last week we randomly tried putting her in bed immediately when we got home and she miraculously fell right asleep (I'm the one who previously asked you about a 2-hour pre-nap-crib-hangout girl- we're working on that!) and then just had her lunch a little later and afternoon nap at normal time! We'll see in the future if that works again or if it was a fluke.
May 6, 2008 5:36 PM
- LHS Class of 1998 said...
Thank you so much for this post Val! Megan:-)
May 6, 2008 8:35 PM
You are welcome Megan!
May 7, 2008 2:11 PM
- Catherine said...
What a great article! Thank you!
May 6, 2008 10:11 PM
You are welcome Catherine! Thanks!
May 7, 2008 2:12 PM
- Jennifer Brewer said...
Thanks, this is a great post! I am really blessed that my husband has an office at church! I am able to lay Gabby down for her morning nap before I take her to the nursery. Whew! What a blessing. Her morning nap is her best nap. Glad we don't have to miss it.
May 7, 2008 7:00 AM
Jennifer, that sounds wonderful! I am jealous!
May 7, 2008 2:14 PM
- Krystal said...
Our church schedule is from 11-2. My daughter's nap goes from 10-12-so chuch lands right in the middle. (of course). She gets up at 8am every morning, and I just put her down at 9 on sunday's so that she gets about 1 1/2 hrs. of sleep before church. Then when we get home at 2:15ish, she goes down again until about 4-4:30. She does get a little cranky at church, but not too bad. I hope that helps someone!
May 9, 2008 10:31 AM
May 9, 2008 10:54 AM
- MarthaStuart said...
Our church is from 8:15a-11:00a and we live 45 minutes away. Since my son normally eats at 7a & 11a and takes a nap from 8a-11a I feed him right before we leave (7am) and have the nursery worker lay him down for a nap at 8a. I then feed him after Sunday School (11a)before we leave for home. He sometimes will sleep in the crib or other times in someone's arms. Generally Sundays are rough and I end up holding him for part of a nap later in the day, but over all it works alright. Previously he was on a 3 hour schedule and I was able to get him up early (6:30a) and feed him during coffee hour (9:30a), which worked quite well also. He is now 11 weeks old and things on Sunday run a bit smoother than they did at first. :)
November 15, 2008 3:53 PM
Thanks for sharing that MarthaStuart!
November 22, 2008 3:45 PM
- Emily said...
Thanks for your response on solids on Sundays. I'm going to try that next Sunday. I have another solid question. My DD takes forever to eat solids and occasionaly(rarely) we need to leave and there's no time. Is it okay if on those occasions I give her solids later (maybe 30 minutes later or so)? Also, what and when were the first finger foods you used? Thanks, this whole eating thing is very new to me!
August 19, 2008 11:35 AM
Emily, that would be fine. I would keep it the exception rather than the norm, but it would be fine to do that sometimes. See this post on finger foods: Finger Foods: http://babywisemom.blogspot.com/2007/12/finger-foods.html
August 19, 2008 9:14 PM
- Mahal said...
Hi, we are on day 5 of CIO bootcamp (and very late starters with BW) with our 15WO daughter. You recommended in another blog to dedicate 2 weeks for sleep training. We don't want to confuse her progress with church on Sunday. Do you recommend that we stay home this Sunday and the next in order for her sleep training to be more concrete? What did you do? I know you started BW late with your son, so did you sacrifice church for a few weeks? Any suggestions would be very helpful.
October 17, 2008 11:21 AM
Mahal, sorry this is late for you for Sunday. I didn't stay home with my son for church. Church is really important to us and I just had faith that in going to church the Lord would bless us :) With my daughter, I started her from birth and we stayed home from church for the first month to recover from birth and to avoid the end of RSV season, so she did have complete consistency. However, if she had started late I still would have gone to church.
October 20, 2008 4:35 PM
No problem, I understand and I realize you are not getting paid for this awesome service. I'm thankful that you are sharing your experiences online.We did go to church this past Sunday. She did better than I thought! She took a nap in her sling during service and then in her car seat on the way home (our service is during two of her naps). I'm so glad we didn't stay home. Thanks again!
October 23, 2008 12:32 PM
Mahal, Thanks for your understanding! I am glad things went well for you!
November 10, 2008 4:31 PM
- B. B. said...
You mentioned that you have your kids sit on daddy's lap in the hallway if they can not sit still in the meeting. Just curious, at what age did you implement this? My son is 9 months and crawling. It just seems at his age like it is too much to ask for him to sit still for 3 hours without being able to crawl around and move a bit. Especially because I feel he doesn't have the cognitive ability to understand "sitting still," etc. Are my expectations just too low?
November 8, 2008 2:02 PM
BB, We don't require them to sit perfectly still. But they can't crawl around or walk around the church or room. We have three different rooms we sit in. The first is the chapel where we sit on a bench and it has bit more room for the kids. The next is sunday school where there is basically enough room for them to sit on the floor or on a chair. The third is similar to sunday school. We are also there for 3 hours. I think you can expect him to pretty much sit "still"--meaning I don't think he needs to crawl around. If you have breaks between things, let him get wiggles out then. It is hard for the little ones, and I would be more lenient if possible the third hour (without allowing things that are "no's"). Before we had children, we were in an area where there were lots of young families. Most had only one child. This area also happend to have most parents who followed BW. There were some who didn't and allowed their kids to run around and play as babies. I watched them grow into toddlers that were quite disruptive and wouldn't stay in classroom but wanted to go into the hall where they would play. If they couldn't play in the hall, they played in the classroom. I saw that starkly contrasted with the BW babies who sat still and played through church. It is really what turned me on to BW in the first place. At 9 months he definitely can understand. Adjust to how you know him, but always be aware that what you allow now will only magnify as he gets older. Crawling seems innocent, but it morphs to walking then running. The child who was allowed to crawl won't be easy to tell 'no, you can't walk around the room at will.'
November 10, 2008 4:55 PM