Consequences: Natural VS Logical and How to Use Each

5
(4)

Learn all about what a natural consequence is and what a logical consequence is and tips for using each type. Learn also when to intervene.

Child look up in frustration

I think the most powerful discipline tool you have as a parent is consequences.

If X, then Y.

It sounds simple enough, right?

Well, we all know raising children isn’t ever that simple, so let’s try to elaborate.

There are two types of consequences: Natural and Logical.

Natural Consequences

Natural consequences are something that happens naturally when you do something.

Maybe your child is bugging the cat over and over even after being told not to and the cat scratches him.

The pain from the scratch is the natural consequence. It is a natural course of action that happened because the child continued to pester the cat.

Another example of a natural consequence is getting cold because you didn’t put a coat on. If you instructed your child to get a coat before heading out the door and he doesn’t, then him getting cold later is a natural consequence he can learn from.

Natural consequences are pretty easy because you don’t have to do anything as the parent. They naturally happen.

Natural vs. Logical Consequences pinnable image

Logical Consequences

Logical consequences are consequences you either create or simply allow to happen as the parent.

I use logical consequences more than any other tool in disciplining. They work well for my brain; I am very logical.

Logical consequences are the types of consequences most often discussed in Parenting With Love and Logic.

Read: Parenting With Love and Logic: Everything You Need to Know

Here are some examples of logical consequences.

Don’t pick up your toys? You might lose that toy for a time.

Can’t get along with your sibling? Then you don’t get to play with your sibling.

Didn’t eat your dinner? Don’t expect an early breakfast.

Did you turn on the TV without asking? I guess you lost TV for a few days.

Did you mis-use a toy and hit your brother with it? Then you don’t get to play with it.

Did you color on the table on purpose? No more coloring today.

I think logical consequences can sound harsh. The parent sounds compassion-less and strictly judgmental.

Using logical consequences means you are allowing your child to learn from decisions and actions taken. But we don’t have to be robots. We can allow there to be grace along with allowing consequences.

Read: 10 Guidelines for Using Logical Consequences

I honestly see people in chat groups that say they don’t let their child experience consequences as they come. They shield them. They protect them. They are only children after all!

Fuzzy Line of Consequences

Here is the fuzzy line of consequences.

There are consequences that happen pretty automatically and can be considered natural, except they are controlled by people.

Let’s say your child was late for school because he wouldn’t get out of bed. The school docks his grade unless it is an excused tardy.

You, the parent, have the power to offer the excuse.

This is a situation when consequences get difficult.

You want your child to have good grades. Think of the importance of the grades in his life! But you also don’t want to bail him out for being a slacker.

This is a situation I believe you have him accept the consequences for his actions. I am sure some will disagree, but I think most experts agree with me on this.

I would have him take the grade hit. He didn’t get out of bed and he needs to face all of the consequences that brings with it. He will need to work to make up for that grade hit.

And he probably will make sure he gets out of bed next time.

Read: Should You Bail Your Child Out?

It is harder than you might think to allow your child to face consequences. It is not easy to watch our children struggle at all.

Our world is gaining more and more people unwilling to accept the consequences of their actions. Nothing is ever their fault.

Even something like running out of money in the checking account isn’t their fault. It must be someone else’s. The bank didn’t tell them. So-and-so took a long time to cash a check so they thought they had more money than they did.

We are constantly looking for bail outs.

Most people who refuse to accept responsibility for actions were raised by parents who felt bad for the child and removed these natural consequences in life.

It was done out of love, but in the long-run, it didn’t do the child any favors. At some point, we all face someone who expects us to answer for our actions.

Using Consequences as a Discipline Tool pinnable image

Teach While Stakes are Low

I like the thought from the book Parenting With Love and Logic. The book says you need to teach consequences while the stakes are low.

Say your 2 year old is absolutely devastated that she can’t color any more today since she intentionally colored on the table instead of the paper (real life example from my own life with a two year old).

She had the perfect little sad face and the tears fell just right. Her big eyes were brimming. Her lip pouted just so. She hugged me in despair.

It is easy to think, “oh, she is repentant. I am going to forgive her and give back these crayons.”

How likely do you think she is going to be to color on that table again? Very. I would bet she colors on the table again that same night.

Let’s say instead you think, “Oh good. She is experiencing the pain of a consequence. From my perspective, losing crayons for one day is not a big deal in her life. I am going to let her ride this out.”

You hug her. You tell her you know she is sad. And you explain that she made a choice and she doesn’t get to color for the rest of the day because of her actions.

Perhaps by starting on this path now, you are better equipped to avoid her losing her license for traffic violations. Or maybe she will be sure to work hard in school and stay on top of her grades.

She will not always be able to turn on the charm and cry her way out of situations in life. At some point, someone somewhere is going to call her out and force her to face the choice she made.

If it isn’t you, it will be friends, school, bosses, law enforcement, the bank…someone will do it. It is an easier lesson to learn on crayons than on a mortgage.

But let’s take this up a level. I think most of you are desirous of more for your children than avoiding getting into financial or legal trouble.

As Walter Williams once put it,

“Laws Are a Poor Substitute for Common Decency, Moral Values.”

Walter Williams

Just because something is “legal” doesn’t make it right morally.

We want to teach our children to understand that actions have consequences while they are young so they can learn to apply this understanding in their lives morally.

With this ability, they can be internally driven to do what is right rather than simply trying to stay within the bounds of the law.

Logical consequences are hard. They take consistency and resolve. They require that you listen to more crying and whining than you would otherwise.

It is always easier in the moment to give your child just one more chance.

Keep the end goal in mind.

You are the parent. It is your job to teach the effects of choices and consequences.

Yours.

The world will hand the consequences out. It is your job to prepare your child while the stakes are low.

And in the end, you want your child choosing the right even if there are no obvious consequences attached to doing something wrong.

Another example of low stakes found in Love and Logic is the idea of getting hurt. The authors basically say that you should allow your young toddler to get hurt while the stakes are low.

Now, this doesn’t mean you hand her a knife or put her up at the top of the stairs and say “jump!” You still need to make her environment safe.

But it means you don’t hover. You allow her to trip and fall. You allow her to go walk on the rocks and discover they are pokey.

My caveat with this idea is I think you first need to educate the child, and you also need to allow things age appropriately.

You tell your child the rocks are pokey and it will hurt her feet to walk on them–and this is assuming she is old enough to understand what you are telling her.

You don’t put your toddling 12 month old down on the ground just let her go for the rocks. So protect as age appropriate and teach before allowing consequences to take place.

And then let your child learn.

Sometime, your child is going to take a physical risk. It will be best if he did it while the stakes were low.

He can understand what pain feels like and that he isn’t superman after all in a low-stakes situation.

If he goes through his toddler years being protected from every fall, then as his physical abilities improve, and therefore his ability to take higher risks improve, he has a greater chance of getting hurt, and hurt seriously.

You can’t hover forever. Someday, he will be somewhere without you.

I remember this thought being powerful to me with Brayden. I was the hovering mom trying to make sure he never felt pain.

I caught him before he hit the floor–every single time. I finally let go and allowed him to do age-appropriate things where he might get hurt.

With Kaitlyn, I was awesome at stepping back and letting her have that freedom she needed from the beginning.

There was a stark contrast between how Brayden handled pain and Kaitlyn.

Remember Context

While applying logical consequences, remember context.

When your child is sick, teething, tired, or hungry, have extra patience for your child.

You also want to be sure your child knew there would be a consequence. You have to be careful here. If you told your child, you need to follow through. Don’t think, “Oh, he probably didn’t hear me”. It is important to follow through.

This is why requiring a “Yes, Mommy” and utilizing Ask and Tell are so helpful. You both know you both understood.

Logical consequences are a just action. As the parent, you need to be sure you apply mercy here, also.

Use your best judgment to know how much to ignore during these tired and sore times for your child.

Conclusion

Don’t underestimate the power of consequences. I really think if you can apply and allow consequences appropriately, you don’t have to do much else in the form of correction.

While I don’t love everything in Love and Logic, I think it is great for getting you in the mindset of applying logical consequences. There is also some discussion of consequences in On Becoming Preschool Wise.

RELATED POSTS

This post originally appeared on this blog in February 2010

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it 1-5!

Average rating 5 / 5. Vote count: 4

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

As you found this post useful...

Follow us on social media!

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

21 thoughts on “Consequences: Natural VS Logical and How to Use Each”

  1. I really like this idea of logical consequences but I'm having a hard time coming up with a logical consequence of running away when it's time to do something. My son loves to play "chase" and I spend at least half an hour a day chasing him in the yard, or around his crib, or around the kitchen table. I make it very clear that we are playing a game. He usually starts it by saying "chase me mama!" and then I respond by saying "I'm gonna get you" in a playful tone. But when it's time to get ready for dinner, or to go to the store, or to get ready for bed, he runs away as well. I tell him it's not a game and we're not playing chase but he continues to try to evade me. What would be a good logical consequence for this? If anyone has any ideas, I'd love to hear them. My son is almost 2 (his b-day is in March) and can understand and communicate very well. So I know he knows what I'm saying when I tell him it's not a game!

    Reply
  2. Janelle, if it were me in that situation, I would pick him up and carry him if he ran. I know around that age my two older kids HATED to be carried…they wanted to "do it themselves"…so if they did something like that, I would just carry them.

    Reply
  3. Great & timely post! I've really been thinking about this a LOT this past week. I too think logical consequences can be the most effective but often have trouble coming up with an appropriate consequence on the spot for an item. I requested the Love & Logic book from the library and hope they have some examples. Do they have specific examples? I know you've listed a few and the wise books list a few, but obviously there are a lot in everyday life. My just turned 3 YO is testing me a lot now and just doing things on purpose (clearly hearing and understanding me) that I told her not to do. I am not sure if this is an age thing as it really seemed that this "testing" has picked up a lot as she just turned 3. Anyways I am rereading Childwise and really thinking hard about this. She is treating it all as a big game and not treating anything seriously. I have been requiring the Yes Mom and know that after that if she doesn't listen I have to employ something. Anyways I guess I just need help being more creative:)

    Reply
  4. Wow! Good post! My Lo is 18months at the moment and she is already testing my consistency! I battled for a week with her ignoring me, and then I tried time out which did not work and eventually I told her I'm going to take away her Teddy if she doesn't listen [She did not want to lie down in her crib for her nap] she then again did not listen so I took away her Teddy and she cried awhile before falling asleep, and the previous day she did not want to stay in her room for room time so when she woke up I told her she could have her teddy back when she playe nicely in her room until the timer goes off!! It worked!! After the timer went off she immediately showed me the way to the teddy and I gave it to her… Its amazing how well they understand!! And when you get to know their personality you accomplish a lot!! I thought I was being to harsh on her but according to this blog I'm not…. Thank you 🙂 For making me feel better amd proud of myself!!

    Reply
  5. Hi, I follow your blog through Google reader. I'm a first time Mom and this blog has been a life saver at times. Thank you so much.

    Reply
  6. Hi if i win I will be ordering the Mint Pink Paisley/Soft Pink w/White Satin Sheety blanket for my daughter it will match her room perfectly.

    Reply
  7. If I win I will have the words to Twinkle Twinkle Little Star printed on the because I sing that song to my daughter before every nap and at bedtime.

    Reply
  8. Nicolette,you need to put your entry comments on the blanket giveaway post. I don't know if you realized you are putting them on the consequences post 🙂

    Reply
  9. Thank you for your thoughts on this. I love your opening paragraph under logical consequences. Very straight-forward and I can see the line of thinking. I'm definitely improving in this. My hang up with logical consequences has been when when the consequence might lead to another problem. For example, if I take away his toys (not A toy)for the morning, I'm not going to let DS wander the house. That's just asking for trouble. So it means I need to have something else for him to do in place of the time he would have been playing with the toys, you know?Thanks for the great post!

    Reply
  10. I agree wholeheartedly. I listened to a talk recently regarding people's general lack of moral compasses. The speaker stated that even if we keep making laws, people will continue to find their way around them, because what they need to have is just an inner moral compass to guide their actions because that will ultimately be the only thing making people make good decisions. You appear to have just the same amount of patience with the adults around us who flat out REFUSE to take responsibility for their own actions. I find myself using these standards not only on my daughter but on my husband and on myself as well. Even when I've gotten issued a driving citation, I usually agree with the police officer (not to his face 🙂 that I deserved the ticket. My mom always gets upset with the officer, and I say, "YOU were breaking the law and you know it!"As far as your tardy example goes, I recall a handful of times as early as 7 years old that my mom would remind me to set my alarm the night before, and if I slept in she wouldn't wake me for school and never, ever write me a note. At my school we not only had to suffer a docked grade, but also had detention during lunch and recess. I remember so very clearly how my blood boiled when I knew my mother was awake and could've woken me up but did not. When I would tell my friends at school they were so surprised that she wouldn't wake me up. I resented her at the time immensely. But now as an adult, I fully take responsibility for my own actions. I would say it is one of the aspects of my person that I am the most proud of. Stick with the logical consequences because it really helps kids understand the real world.

    Reply
  11. i'm happy to have found this blog–i have 3 little boys (all BWed). you have a great variety of help and i know i need it for my 10 week old but even for my 2 and 5–looking at this post! thanks.

    Reply
  12. My cousin introduced me to your blog while I was pregnant, and it has been very refreshing to follow. I've thoroughly enjoy it! My baby boy is 11 weeks now, and I also have a 4 1/2 year old boy and an almost 3 year old girl. I liked this post because I am also very logical in my consequences. But what I am having a hard time with is that the consequences don't seem to make much of an impression because within a few minutes it seems like they are doing the same thing that they just got in trouble for. Do you find yourself saying the exact same things over and over? Sometimes I feel like nothing I am saying is sinking in with them. Any suggestions for making this process less frustrating? On a different note, my two oldest children are from my husband's first marriage. Their mother past away, and my husband and I have been married for almost 2 years. I know you are in contact with many moms. Have you met anyone with a similar situation? Sometimes I feel very alone in the experiences I have as a step-mom and now as a first-time mom. Thank you for your posts.

    Reply
  13. YS, Love and Logic has lots of examples. Many of them are way beyond the age of a toddler. They also have a book for toddler age, which I intend to buy soon, so I don't know what it is like. I think the book is valuable just to get you in the right frame of mind of how to apply consequences.

    Reply
  14. Ben & Jenny,I wouldn't take every toy away–just the one(s) being abused. Or if the toy had nothing to do with why it was taken away, just the one(s) that mean the most to him because it will cause him to take notice the most.I get what you are saying. When I take away TV or nintendo from Brayden, it always means more work for me 🙂 We usually do extra learning activities or I have him help more with chores (he likes to do that).

    Reply
  15. Amber, to an extent, there will be a lot of repeating yourself.However, if you aren't seeing improvement (repeating yourself less often 🙂 ), then what you are doing probably isn't the best option.Try either changing what the logical consequence is, or try something else all together.So far as the family set up, I can't think of anyone specifically in that situation in any BW groups. However, there are a lot of people in both the Babycenter Babywise group and the Chronicles Yahoo Group. I would try posting a message asking that in one or both groups and see if there is someone in that situation.

    Reply
  16. Melissa, see the blog label "hitting" for a post on the topic. In short, I would probably immediately take the 2 year old away from the baby and put him in time out. No nonsense. I would then tell him for the rest of the playtime or even day, "I am sorry. You aren't allowed to play with baby today. You weren't kind." I would also spend time teaching him how to appropriately express physical love if that is what he is going for. I know Kaitlyn can be rough when she wants to express love.If it is out of anger (like a "don't steal my toy" thing), I would also remove whatever he was so angry about. If he hit over a toy, I would take the toy away. Be no nonsense, but don't get angry. Anger from a parent doesn't help the child learn from the situation.

    Reply

Leave a Comment